Croudace's appeal for 480 homes off Shillingford Road, Wallingford, goes to a public inquiry at Howbery Park from 5 January. The council refused it in March.
A plan for up to 480 homes on farmland west of Shillingford Road in Wallingford goes before a planning inspector on Tuesday 5 January 2027. Croudace Homes is appealing against South Oxfordshire District Council’s refusal of the scheme in March.
The public inquiry opens at 10am at the Fountain Conference Centre, Howbery Park, Benson Lane, Wallingford. It is listed to run for 10 days, with inspector P Ware. The details are on the council’s planning register for application P24/S3481/O, Planning Inspectorate reference 6011175.
Wallingford is about 11 miles north-west of Henley.
Overview
- What: outline plans for up to 400 homes and up to 80 homes for older people, with sports pitches, a clubhouse and open space.
- Where: about 22.9 hectares of farmland west of Shillingford Road, between Wallingford and Brightwell-cum-Sotwell.
- Refused: 25 March 2026, for five reasons.
- Inquiry: from Tuesday 5 January 2027, 10am, Fountain Conference Centre, Howbery Park.
- Opposing the appeal: the district council and Wallingford Town Council, which raised £10,500 to make its case.
What Croudace wants to build
The application asks for outline permission, with only the road accesses fixed now. According to the description on the register, the scheme includes:
- up to 400 homes
- up to 80 age-restricted homes for older people
- affordable housing
- sports pitches with a clubhouse and parking
- vehicle accesses from Shillingford Road
- public open space, landscaping and wildlife improvements
Croudace’s statement of case to the inspector, dated June 2026, says 40% of the homes would be affordable. That is up to 192 homes. It cites 3,449 households on the district’s housing waiting list.
The developer also says the sports hub has been designed around Wallingford Castle Archers. The statement describes the club as having more than 200 members and training at Wallingford School, Didcot Girls’ School and Wallingford Sports Park. It says the grass pitches could also be used by Wallingford School.
Why the council said no
The district council’s decision notice, signed by its head of planning on 25 March, gives five reasons:
- The site is not allocated for housing and is outside the built-up limits of Wallingford and Brightwell-cum-Sotwell, so it counts as open countryside. Building on it would also stop sand and gravel being dug from land safeguarded for minerals.
- It would harm the setting of the North Wessex Downs National Landscape and the landscape setting of Wallingford.
- No legal agreement was in place to secure the affordable housing.
- No legal agreement was in place to secure a 10% gain in biodiversity.
- No legal agreement was in place for roads, schools and other infrastructure, and the effect on school places had not been shown to be manageable.
The rules changed in August
The government published a new National Planning Policy Framework on 17 August 2026. The district council filed an addendum to its case in October to deal with it.
The addendum accepts that the council cannot show a five-year supply of land for housing. Its own housing land supply report, published in September, puts the figure at 3.98 years. That is down from the 4.46 years in the council’s previous statement.
The report’s table sets it out:
| Homes | |
|---|---|
| Five-year need, 1 April 2026 to 31 March 2031, with a 5% buffer | 6,342 |
| Deliverable supply | 5,044 |
| Shortfall | 1,298 |
Under the new framework, the council says, that shortfall counts as an “evidenced unmet need”. That opens the door to homes outside a town, but only if the site is “physically well-related” to it and the roads, schools and services can cope.
The council will argue that this site is not. It says the land touches Wallingford along only one edge, and that there is no railway station within a walk of about 800 metres.
The council also concedes one point. A Wallingford Neighbourhood Plan policy limiting building outside the town’s boundary now carries “very limited weight”, because it conflicts with the new national policy. The council says the other policies it lists keep their full weight.
Wallingford Town Council joins the inquiry
The town council has registered as a “Rule 6 party”. That gives it a formal place at the inquiry, with its own evidence and witnesses. Its statement of case says it backs all five reasons for refusal. It will concentrate on the first two: the countryside and the landscape.
It paid for that with a public appeal. On 16 October the town council said it had raised the £10,500 it needed for professional and legal costs, through a Crowdfunder and donations at its offices.
What it means for you
Anyone can go. The Planning Inspectorate’s guide to taking part in an inquiry says inquiries “are open to journalists and the wider public”. Residents have no legal right to speak, but it says “the Inspector will normally allow you to do so”.
The deadline for written comments is normally five weeks from an appeal’s start date. This appeal started on 6 July, so that window has closed. The documents from both sides, and the comments already sent, are on the council’s register under the Appeals tab.
The inspector will decide the appeal, not the council. A decision usually follows some weeks after an inquiry closes.
This is one of three housing appeals in the district the register lists for inquiry. The others are up to 200 homes at Sires Hill, Didcot, listed for inquiry from 13 October, and the 170 homes at Watlington Road, Benson, which we reported in October.
Have your say