Elivia Homes has appealed over South Oxfordshire's failure to decide its plan for up to 170 homes off Watlington Road, Benson. It will go to a public inquiry.

The developer behind a plan for up to 170 homes on the edge of Benson has taken it to the Planning Inspectorate before the district council made a decision. Elivia Homes (Central) Ltd lodged a non-determination appeal on 8 October, according to South Oxfordshire District Council’s planning register.

The appeal will be heard at a public inquiry. No start date, inquiry date or inspector had been published on 30 October.

Benson is about 11 miles north-west of Henley, between Wallingford and Watlington.

What is proposed

The application, P26/S1811/O, is for outline permission for up to 170 homes on land south of Watlington Road. Every detail except the access is left for later. The council received it on 26 May 2026.

The register gave 30 September as the deadline for a decision, after an agreed extension. That date passed with the application still “Under Consideration” and “Not Yet Recommended”. Elivia filed amended plans and a reply to the county council’s highways comments in September, and a road safety audit on 5 October.

In a non-determination appeal, the Planning Inspectorate decides the application in place of the council. The council’s planning committee does not get a vote on it.

Why the parish council objects

Benson Parish Council and the village’s neighbourhood plan team said they “object strongly” in a response dated 26 July.

The parish council calls it a “rerun” of Elivia’s 2016 application on the same land, P16/S3441/O. That scheme started at 180 homes and was cut to 120 during an appeal and a call-in by the Secretary of State. The appeal was dismissed, the parish council says.

Its main objections are:

  • The site is outside the village boundary set in the neighbourhood plan, so the district’s countryside policies apply
  • The homes could be too tall. The developer’s heights plan allows ridges of up to 10.5 metres. The neighbourhood plan’s design rules call for two storeys or less on the village edge
  • The village has grown fast. The parish council counts 831 new homes built since 2018, 565 of them allocated in its own plan. It says that is a 62% increase on the 1,350 homes Benson had
  • The relief road is late. The parish council says it is now unlikely to open fully before summer 2027
  • The access onto Watlington Road would, it argues, send drivers through the village centre instead of onto the relief road
  • Services are stretched. It says Wallingford School is short of places and local health services are close to capacity

The parish council also says 170 was chosen to bring the scheme over the government’s new 150-home threshold. Under a planning direction that took effect this year, a council that proposes to refuse 150 or more homes must first refer the application to the Secretary of State. That is the parish council’s reading of the developer’s motive, not a statement from Elivia.

The last Benson appeal

The parish council points to the most recent appeal decision in the village, at The Orchard, Braze Lane (P24/S3131/FUL). It says the inspector in that case gave “substantial weight” to the neighbourhood plan and the district’s countryside policies.

What it means for you

Comments to the council have closed, but the appeal will have its own. Once the Planning Inspectorate starts the appeal, it sets a deadline for “interested party” comments. The council normally writes to people who commented on the application. The appeal reference is 6017256.

A public inquiry is held in public. Anyone can attend, and the inspector can let local people speak. The date and venue will appear on the council’s register and on the Planning Inspectorate’s casework portal.

Nothing has been approved. The application is undecided, and the inspector can allow or dismiss it. New planning applications in the district are on our planning page.

Sources