Waitrose says Henley's Aldi would cut its food sales by up to 14%, against Aldi's own 8.2%. The 15 October decision date has passed with nothing decided.

Waitrose has formally objected to Aldi’s plan for a supermarket on Reading Road in Henley. It says the new store would take far more trade from its Bell Street shop than Aldi has admitted.

The objection was written by the planning consultancy Firstplan on Waitrose’s behalf. It is dated 18 September and was filed on the South Oxfordshire planning register on 21 September, two days after public comments closed.

The council has still not decided the application. The register gave 15 October as the target date. On the morning of 19 October it still read “Under Consideration” and “Not Yet Recommended”.

Updated 26 October: on 22 October the Competition and Markets Authority confirmed that Aldi and Lidl are now “Large Grocery Retailers”, under the same land agreement rules as Tesco and Waitrose. The CMA said Waitrose was among the supermarkets that backed the change, and Aldi made no representations. The planning register still read “Under Consideration” and “Not Yet Recommended” on 26 October, with no new expiry date shown.

Updated 6 November: the register now shows an extension date and expiry date of 4 December 2026, which suggests the council and Aldi have agreed more time; the register says the date is a guide and may change. No decision, no committee date and no new documents since the forestry reply of 27 October.

Updated 30 October: the council’s forestry officer replied on 27 October. The officer has no objection on the trees being felled, subject to a tree protection condition, but says the lack of any new trees in the car park “is not acceptable” and the parking layout “needs to be amended”. The register still shows no decision, no new expiry date and no reply from Aldi.

The numbers the two supermarkets disagree on

Aldi’s case rests on its Planning and Retail Statement, written by Avison Young in July. It forecasts that the Henley Aldi would take £11.85m a year in food and grocery sales by 2030.

Aldi’s statement says that money would come mainly from the two big stores already in town:

  • Tesco Extra, Reading Road: £5.73m, a 14.7% fall in its food turnover
  • Waitrose, Bell Street: £2.43m, a fall of 8.2%
  • Henley town centre as a whole: £2.73m, a fall of 8.0%

Aldi expects Tesco to lose about twice as much as Waitrose. Its reasons are that Tesco is cheaper, closer (a two-minute drive against four) and busier.

Waitrose does not accept that. Its letter says its store is nearer in size to the planned Aldi than Tesco is. It argues that 30% to 35% of the Aldi’s food sales would come from Waitrose, not 21%.

On that basis, Waitrose puts the hit to its own food turnover at 12.0% to 14.0%, or £3.56m to £4.15m a year.

Bar chart of the forecast fall in Waitrose Henley's convenience goods turnover in 2030 if the Aldi opens: 8.2% in Aldi's own retail statement, against 12.0% and 14.0% in Waitrose's objection.
Chart by The Henley Post. Sources: Aldi's Planning and Retail Statement (Avison Young, July 2026) and Waitrose's objection (Firstplan, 18 September 2026).
Share this chartFacebookWhatsAppX

Waitrose’s five objections

The letter makes five points against Aldi’s retail case:

  • Aldi should not be treated as a different kind of shop from the main supermarkets
  • the fact that Tesco and Waitrose are busier than average is not a reason to add a third store
  • Aldi’s check on the health of Henley town centre is too thin, at eight paragraphs
  • the trade Aldi would take from Waitrose has been underestimated
  • no account has been taken of shoppers who visit Waitrose and then spend in other town centre businesses

On the first point, Waitrose cites the Competition and Markets Authority. On 7 August the CMA provisionally decided that Aldi and Lidl no longer count as “limited assortment discounters”. It now proposes to treat them as large grocery retailers, under the same land agreement rules as Tesco and Waitrose. The CMA confirmed that decision on 22 October.

The CMA rules are about land deals, not planning. They stop a designated supermarket from using covenants or exclusivity clauses to block a rival opening nearby. They do not decide whether Henley gets an Aldi. That is still the district council’s call.

On the town centre, Waitrose’s letter says Henley has 26 empty shop units, a vacancy rate of just under 10%. That figure is Waitrose’s own; Aldi’s statement says the centre is “performing well”.

Waitrose says it has traded in Henley since 1965, and from the Bell Street store since 1994. It asks the council not to decide the application until Aldi supplies “full and robust justification” on all five points.

If the council does approve it, Waitrose asks for a condition fixing the store at 80% food and 20% non-food, as Aldi has proposed.

What Aldi says in reply

Aldi has not yet answered the letter on the register. Its statement already argues that both Henley stores would stay healthy. It says that even after the Aldi opened, Waitrose would still take about £6.83m a year more than the national average for a store its size, which is 134% of its benchmark.

The statement also says the store would create about 40 jobs. It adds that the council’s own retail evidence found Waitrose and Tesco both trading well above benchmark, which Aldi reads as proof the town needs more choice.

Waitrose reads the same figures the other way. It says that spending is kept in the town centre, and that this is a good thing.

Where the application stands

Waitrose’s letter is the most detailed objection yet. It is not the only problem the scheme faces:

  • Oxfordshire County Council objected on transport and drainage in September, over 95 car parking spaces against a maximum of 62. We reported that objection here. No revised plans or new survey data from Aldi had been filed by 19 October.
  • Henley Town Council recommended refusal in August.
  • The council’s urban design officer asked on 18 September for a fuller design statement, eye-level drawings, more planting and permeable paving across the car park.
  • The council’s forestry officer replied on 27 October, raising no objection to the five tree features Aldi would remove, which include a Leyland cypress hedge, if they are replaced and the retained trees are protected. But the response says the scheme “fails to comply” with Local Plan design policies DES1 and DES2 because it plants no new trees in the car park, and asks for the layout and the species list to change.
  • The Environment Agency and the drainage team had still not replied on 30 October.

Public support has kept growing. On 19 October the register showed 172 comments in support, 34 objections and 7 neutral. On 21 September it showed 141, 31 and 7.

What it means for you

No decision has been made, and none is imminent. The 15 October date on the register was a guide. When a statutory consultee objects and plans need changing, councils commonly agree an extension of time with the applicant.

Comments are closed, but the register still updates. Waitrose has reserved the right to comment again on anything new Aldi submits. Aldi’s answer to the county’s highways objection is the next document to watch.

It has not yet been decided who will rule on it. It could be a council officer or the planning committee. Henley Town Council has said it will speak if it goes to committee.

Nothing changes on the ground. Jewson is still trading at 99 Reading Road. Parking around Waitrose and the Kings Road car park is on our Henley parking page, and new applications are on our Henley planning page.

Sources

  • Application P26/S2960/FUL, South Oxfordshire District Council planning register, read on the morning of 19 October 2026, for the status, the 15 October expiry date, the consultee reply list and the comment totals.
  • Firstplan on behalf of Waitrose & Partners, objection letter dated 18 September 2026, filed on the register on 21 September 2026, for the five objections, the 30% to 35% diversion and 12.0% to 14.0% impact estimates, the vacancy figures, the trading history and the requested condition.
  • Avison Young for Aldi Stores Ltd, Planning and Retail Statement, July 2026 (on the register, 16 July 2026), Table 4.1 and Tables 2, 13 and 14, for the £11.85m turnover, the trade diversion and impact figures, the benchmark comparison and the 40 jobs.
  • South Oxfordshire District Council urban design consultation response, 18 September 2026.
  • South Oxfordshire District Council forestry team consultation response, 27 October 2026, on the planning register, for the tree removals, the TPO and conservation area, the car park planting and the DES1 and DES2 finding.
  • Competition and Markets Authority, final decision press release, 22 October 2026.
  • Competition and Markets Authority, press release and case page, 7 August 2026.